UVA was on the front page of Sunday’s Metro section of The Washington Post. The story rehashed concerns about the University’s 150-year-old honor code and its "single sanction," linked to the recent expulsions of two students in the Semester at Sea program, for which UVA is the academic sponsor.
Last week, Mark Gruntz of California Baptist University and Allison Routman of Ohio University were kicked off the boat after failing to properly cite Wikipedia in one of their papers, thus violating UVA’s honor code.
Friends of the two expelled students arguing that the single-sanction punishment is too harsh, reports the Post. Yet other students raised concerns over whether students correctly understand plagiarism and online research.
Gruntz and Routman were assigned to watch a World War II movie and incorporate what they had seen with what they had learned in their Global Studies class. Gruntz said he got in trouble for not citing Wikipedia enough, and Routman for overly relying on the online encyclopedia’s paraphrase of the plot.
The Post reports that the honor code is administered a bit differently on the boat than in UVA’s classrooms. Gruntz’s friends said the treatment of their friend was unfair compared to the far less drastic punishments given to students for drinking.
In the summer of 2006, UVA and the Institute for Shipboard Education announced an agreement that made UVA the academic home for the Semester at Sea program. The partnership was signed by President John T. Casteen III as an effort to give students a broader international learning experience and a far more personal understanding of global issues. The University is in charge of appointing an academic dean and approving a curriculum for each trip.