Local groups are involved in opposition to a very large coal-burning power plant proposed for Surry County. It’s estimated that it would contribute to as many as 200,000 lost work days, due to downwind residents’ health problems, over its 60-year life span. (File photo)
|
Life churns along, and with it a mixed bag of environmental developments in Virginia. The press releases in my inbox right now offer a patchwork reality, in which some environmental issues improve, some worsen, and others get more muddled.
One e-mail tells me that in Virginia, beekeeping is getting more popular—perhaps good news for the decline of bee populations here and everywhere. (Beekeeping class, Ivy Creek Natural Area, April 1: see localfoodhub.org!) Another announces that the EPA is offering help—to the tune of $4 million—to local governments trying to cut down on water pollution that damages the Chesapeake Bay. A third brings the cheerful news that Virginia’s state parks are planning a bunch of special activities for families during the first two weeks of April, when many schoolkids are on spring break.
In the less encouraging department: A state study of proposed uranium mining in the Southside is going to be conducted with little public input and no transparency, by a committee headed up by a former natural gas lobbyist. So much for science.
Vandana Shiva spoke at UVA last Tuesday (see below for more), and she offered clarity amid the confusion. Recent world events, like the Occupy and M15 movements, she believes, are signs of change: the coming of “earth democracy.” She said, “I believe this is unstoppable.”—Erika Howsare
BULLETIN BOARD
Get planted: Monticello’s Center for Historic Plants offers a free open house at Tufton Farm March 31, 10am-4pm, with workshops on wildflower photography, landscaping with native and naturalized plants, and cool-season veggie gardening. So much knowledge! Did we mention it’s free? See monticello.org.
Double X on wheels: Speed-seeking women, take note. Tuesday nights in April, there’s a series of women’s bike classes at Community Bikes on Preston Avenue, in which you can learn how your bike works, how to fix it, and rules for safe riding. Plus: adult bike rodeo! Classes meet April 3, 10, 17 and 24, 6-8pm, with a group bike ride May 5, 9am-noon. $25-75 sliding fee. E-mail shellbellding@gmail.com for registration info.
Teens in the woods: The Virginia State Parks Youth Conservation Corps is taking applications from kids ages 14-17 who’d like to spend three weeks this summer working in a state park with a 10- to 14-member crew. They’ll learn about natural history, teamwork and (we’re guessing) poison ivy. Apply before April 13 at virginiastateparks.gov.
|
Clarion call
Dr. Vandana Shiva names a couple of titans —Einstein and Gandhi—as her inspirations. During her March 20 lecture at UVA, she quoted Einstein to the effect that we cannot solve our problems by using the same mindset that created them. In other words, the environmental crises we face will only worsen if we continue to fight against the Earth rather than work with it.
Dr. Shiva, a philosopher, environmental writer and activist, physicist, and eco-feminist, has been named by Forbes as one of the top seven most influential women in the world, and received the 1993 Right Livelihood Award, the “Alternative Nobel Prize.”
As part of the Brown College Visiting Environmental Writers and Scholars series, Shiva presented a peaceful, non-violent vision for the world and all its forms of life—a notion she calls “earth democracy.” Suggesting that we “re-write the Declaration of Independence for all life,” she insisted that in order to have a “real green economy,” we must respect the rights of all species—not just humans, and certainly not just corporations.
Shiva explained how Monsanto and other large corporations have gained control over the worldwide food industry, particularly through the rapid spread of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) in the name of economic growth. In an article on The Understory, she pointed out that Monsanto wrote the World Trade Organization treaty on Intellectual Property, which forces the patenting of seeds as intellectual property. According to Shiva, such corporate control over the growth, processing, and distribution of food is equally destructive to biodiversity and the livelihoods of farmers, with many being forced off their land.
“Every farmer I know who has left the land faced foreclosure,” Dr. Shiva recalled. She then described the “epidemic of suicides” in India, stating that in the past decade, about 250,000 farmers have committed suicide, usually by drinking pesticides.
With the primacy of “economic growth” comes the use of land as a commodity and, as Shiva said, “the idea that certain people are disposable.”
To protect nature and the human right to food and water, Dr. Shiva founded Navdanya International, through which about 80 community seed banks have been set up. The banks allow farmers to find and trade thousands of seed varieties that have been saved and passed through generations, without genetic interference or corporate domination.
“The more you work with nature, the more food and nutrition you will produce,” Shiva said simply. “The natural role of people is to be a part of nature.”—Laura Ingles
A power plant in the balance
In December 2008, the Old Dominion Electric Cooperative (ODEC) proposed to build the largest coal plant in Virginia, in Surry County. It was to be 1,500 megawatts, in the small town of Dendron (population 272). With Surry County residents leading the way, and advocacy organizations like our Charlottesville-based Appalachian Voices and the Southern Environmental Law Center backing them up, we have so far kept this project from moving ahead.
The regional opposition to the plant comes with good reason. In addition to adding to the demand for mountaintop removal coal, it has been predicted (using EPA-approved methodologies) that this coal plant would cause serious health problems for those downwind over the course of its 60-year lifespan. Among other problems, analysts estimate that pollution from the plant would cause over 1,300 asthma ER visits and contribute to over 2,400 heart attacks and 200,000 lost workdays.
Locals were successful in delaying the initial local zoning approval for a year, but the Dendron Town Council voted in early 2010 to approve the zoning. However, it rushed the process and failed to provide proper public notice, and a lawsuit from a local lawyer and blueberry farmer followed. Over the last two years, during which ODEC tried to keep this suit from going to court, the opposition movement has grown significantly, with people from Richmond to Virginia Beach joining Surry County residents in the fight. The Town of Surry, Isle of Wight County and Southampton County have all opposed the coal plant. Virginia Beach, Williamsburg and Representative Bobby Scott have all officially expressed grave concern. Also opposed are the Norfolk-based Consortium for Infant and Child Health, The Virginia Asthma Coalition and the American Lung Association, as well as nearly every conservation organization in the region.
Recently, the judge ruled in favor of the blueberry farmer, and the Town of Dendron had to hold another public hearing and vote for local zoning. Now, over three years after it proposed the plant, ODEC is just getting around to receiving local zoning approval—and the opposition keeps growing.
At previous public meetings, members of the Dendron Town Council have failed to ask a single substantive question or show anything but blind support for what could be the largest coal-fired power plant in the state. Also, at all five of the previous public hearings the predominantly local speakers have been overwhelmingly opposed to the plant. The meeting on March 5 was no different. Yet after the hearing the Dendron Town Council immediately began reading the motions from pre-printed scripts to approve the massive coal plant, which it did unanimously and without discussion.
So, after a three-year delay, ODEC has achieved its very first, very minor step toward permitting the plant. The broader opposition, already strong across Hampton Roads, just keeps gaining strength, and Appalachian Voices and our partners will ensure that this project never breaks ground.—Mike McCoy
Mike McCoy is the Virginia Campaign Coordinator for Appalachian Voices.