stage
It’s opening night for The Tell-Tale Heart and the Mind of Poe, and things don’t look good for the Endstation Theatre Company, the troupe staging this dramatic analysis of the great Southern writer (and one-time UVA student) Edgar Allan Poe. The small, third-floor theater is far from overflowing—the audience outnumbers the seven-person cast by all of three people. There’s no immediate explanation for the paltry showing.
![]() The Endstation Theatre Company came tapping, as if gently rapping, to Live Arts with The Tell-Tale Heart and the Mind of Poe |
Whatever the reason, the actors seem unfazed. They conduct themselves with brio as the noncrowd trickles in. The tableau consists of an enormous, three-piece dresser holding various knick-knacks including two human mandibles, dead animals in jars of formaldehyde and a dark, mysterious box—the usual gothic fare. Arranged around the dresser, or in cages built into the dresser, are six of the dramatis personae engaged in various activities. A near-catatonic man paces; a girl rocks back and forth, clutching a baby doll with a noose tied around its neck; another man, the Narrator, pounds out frenetic and brilliant beats on various buckets and pots. The seventh cast member, the Doctor, wearing the raiment of a mad scientist, directs the others, who, we come to realize, are his madhouse wards. The madhouse itself, not surprisingly, is Poe’s mind—the patients, aspects of his id; the Doctor, his superego, trying to maintain control.
Over the course of the one-hour play, the six patients recite or enact Poe’s “The Raven,” “Berenice” and “The Tell-Tale Heart,” supersaturated with sudden loud noises, screams and the whispered echoes so popular in cheap horror flicks. The Doctor starts and stops the performances with a cowbell and, along with his reluctant henchman, the Narrator, interjects his own Poe-penned speeches, struggling to preserve decorum as the behavior of his patients becomes increasingly erratic. In the end, he fails; the others, including the Narrator, overpower him, and lock him inside the dresser. The id vanquishes the superego, and madness reigns.
The Tell-Tale Heart and the Mind of Poe succeeds but not without its problems. The storyline—the interplay between the Doctor and his intractable patients—is compelling; it’s a pleasure to hear Poe’s work recited. But the Poe dramatization and the overarching narrative felt disconnected from one another. I found myself so engrossed in the poems and stories themselves that I hardly noticed the goings-on about the stage. Which was just as well—aside from the Doctor (Justin Humphreys) and the excellent Narrator (Joshua Mikel), the acting was largely overwrought. On Thursday, it was Poe himself, not the actors, who carried the night.