Categories
Arts

Writer and a fighter: Larry Kramer’s normal heart

Reposted from 2015. Larry Kramer died from pneumonia on May 27, 2020.

Larry Kramer has had his finger on the pulse of what it is to be a gay man for the past 50 years. His 1978 novel, Faggots, and its depiction of the partying, promiscuous ’70s made him a pariah on Fire Island. His play, The Normal Heart, captured the fear, anger and heartbreak as a mysterious fatal disease decimated the gay community in the 1980s.

However, it’s his work as a gay rights activist that may be the first thing that pops into people’s mind. Kramer is the founder of the Gay Men’s Health Crisis. He also founded the AIDS Coalition to Unleash Power—ACT UP—a group that used civil disobedience to protest the lack of funding, research and treatment for people with AIDS in the ’80s. Its first demonstration blocked rush hour traffic in New York in front of the Food and Drug Administration, the agency Kramer believed was dragging its feet in coming up with treatment for the HIV positive.

“I have no idea how many times I’ve been in jail,” Kramer told C-VILLE via e-mail because of difficulties hearing on the phone. “Less time than I’ve been in hospitals, I’m afraid.”

In 1988, Kramer discovered that he had hepatitis B, was HIV positive and in dire need of a new liver. Mount Sinai Hospital refused to put him on its organ transplant list because people who were HIV positive were considered poor candidates for transplants due to their projected short life spans. Kramer became the poster boy for AIDS/homosexual discrimination, and after news reports that he was dying, he received a new liver in 2001.

It’s “still in good shape, I’m told,” he says.

He says his writing and his activism feed each other. “AIDS gave me my subject matter that set my creativity on fire,” says Kramer.

Growing up Jewish in Bridgeport, Connecticut, Kramer has been an atheist since he was a teen. “But being Jewish has made me fascinated in how we have been eliminated during so much of history, just as gays have,” he says. “I write about this to a huge degree in my new book.”

That book, The American People: Volume I, isn’t the first time he’s observed parallels between Jews and gays. During the AIDS epidemic, he wrote 1989’s Reports from the Holocaust: The Story of an AIDS Activist.

It’s been more than 30 years since acquired immune deficiency syndrome was first observed, and a diagnosis of human immunodeficiency virus infection is no longer a death knell—Kramer has been HIV positive for 27 years. Last year the U.S. Supreme Court ruled states cannot discriminate against gays who want to marry, but assessing the changes he’s seen in his lifetime is not a question Kramer likes to answer.

“We still are not a unified united population, so I don’t think that enough has changed to congratulate ourselves,” he writes. “There is still much work to do. That AIDS is still a plague after 35 years proves how powerless we are.”

The 80-year-old makes his first trip to Charlottesville for the Virginia Film Festival screening of the documentary, Larry Kramer in Love and Anger, and for An Evening with Larry Kramer, both November 8.

Kramer says his husband, David Webster, was “heartbroken” he was turned down to study at the University of Virginia, and went to Columbia instead. Webster, an architect, has been here often and is very knowledgeable about the area’s history, says Kramer. “He knows all about Charlottesville and Jefferson, etc.,” he says.

During the inevitable Q&As with Kramer, here’s a tip about a question he hates: How would you like to be remembered? (C-VILLE asked anyway so you won’t have to.)

“I would like my writing to be recognized for its excellence, rather than its controversy,” he says. “I am usually reviewed as a loud-mouthed activist, not as a good writer.”

Fans of his 1969 Oscar-nominated screenplay for D.H. Lawrence’s Women in Love would disagree.

Categories
Living

The overnighter: Farmville—surprises await in the rural college town

Farmville is not a likely spot for a getaway, unless you’re shopping in the massive Green Front Furniture warehouses or dropping students off at Longwood or Hampden-Sydney colleges. But we’d been hearing from friends who’d been to the quaint, historic town to check out its new High Bridge Trail. And with the opening of a recently renovated historic hotel promising luxury accommodations at a fraction of big-city prices, we couldn’t resist. Luxury—in Farmville?

From Charlottesville, Farmville is an easy hour-and-15-minute, two-lane drive down Route 20 through Scottsville. Approaching town, we switched off the GPS and then cruised the streets casually, taking our time to find the hotel and getting the lay of the land in the compact historic downtown.

The Hotel Weyanoke sits across from Longwood University. Built in 1925, the hotel recently expanded to 70 rooms. The least expensive have a queen bed and go for $99 a night, bumping up to $109 a night on weekends (plus taxes and other fees). We chose a room with two queens and a balcony, which came to $140 all in for a Sunday stay. The accommodations were spacious and deluxe, with mid-century–style furnishings and decorations of small sculptures and stylish vases. Oddly, these items were all glued down (to prevent theft, we guess). In any case, we were thrilled with the oversized shower, the low light, and the sensor that illuminates the bathroom when you walk in (especially helpful in the dark of night). We also appreciated the fridge, wooden tray for breakfast in bed, and the Hamilton Beach coffee maker with refillable filters.

The hotel’s location is perfect for walking to explore downtown. The first diversion to catch our eye was a series of vintage-styled women’s costumes in the window of the Longwood Center for the Visual Arts. Admission is free to the 33,000-square-foot center, a former Rose’s department store. Author and illustrator Victoria Kahn’s “Pinkalicious” exhibition was just ending, and Christopher Reporter’s exhibit of death masks, including Lee Harvey Oswald, was a serious contrast to the pinkaliciousness. The costumes in the window, we learned, were designed for Longwood theater productions like Macbeth and A Midsummer Night’s Dream.

Also on Main Street, Green Front Furniture offers almost a million square feet of high-end wares at discount prices. The furniture mecca encompasses 12 buildings—many of them former tobacco warehouses—and has long been a destination for design-minded Charlottesvillians. But if furniture shopping isn’t your thing, the historic district offers other options. Mainly Clay has handcrafted gifts, pottery supplies, and classes. Gladiola Girls lifestyle boutique boasts “urban chic wear,” something else we wouldn’t have expected in a former tobacco town.

The 32-mile-long High Bridge Trail access point is also on Main Street, about a quarter mile from the Hotel Weyanoke. The former rail bed with finely crushed limestone has been a draw for Charlottesville bicyclists, who rave about how level it is and amenities like picnic tables and toilets along the trail. The actual High Bridge spans 2,400 feet, about 125 feet above the Appomattox River. If you don’t BYOBike, the Outdoor Adventure Store at the access point rents trail cruisers for two hours for $19.95—enough time to get to the High Bridge 4.5 miles away.

After you explore the trail, a glass of wine or a beer awaits at Charley’s Waterfront Café & Wine Bar, just a block from the trailhead. Charley’s has a deck that overlooks the river, and its railing was posted with signs asking people to not feed the goats below, which were busy chomping on the overgrowth along the river bank.

Suitably refreshed after imbibing at Charley’s, we headed back to the hotel for a bite at Effingham’s, a brightly lit restaurant where everything—pizza, calamari, mussels—is coal-fired. Frankly, we weren’t super-impressed with the food, but we were intrigued by the hotel’s seasonal Catbird Rooftop Lounge. It offers birds-eye views of downtown Farmville and oysters on the weekends. We vowed to come back to hang out there in nicer weather.

Ultimately, we satisfied our hunger at the North Street Press Club, which is less than a block from the hotel and across from the Farmville Herald building. Opened this summer, the restaurant, in a renovated brick building, had the most innovative menu we saw in Farmville, with a number of Asian-fusion selections. Chicken tikka tacos and the Venice Beach tuna tacos use naan instead of tortillas, and naan figures in its version of the classic Vietnamese banh mi sandwich, called Naanh Mi (get it?). Most menu items are in the $10 range, so even underpaid reporters—and students—can eat there occasionally.

As cool as the revitalized town feels, Farmville, like many Southern towns, still grapples with its racist past and Prince Edward County’s dubious distinction of closing its public schools for five years rather than integrate. That’s why a visit to the Moton Museum is a must.

The museum is in the former Robert Russa Moton High School, a National Historic Landmark where in 1951 black students went on strike to demand learning conditions equal to those at the white high school. The students convinced the state NAACP to take their case, which became one of five the U.S. Supreme Court considered in its 1954 landmark Brown v. Board of Education ruling that segregated education was unconstitutional.

The free exhibit takes visitors through the conditions at the overcrowded school and its auxiliary tar-paper shacks, the student strike, and Virginia’s response: “massive resistance,” where schools throughout Virginia, including in Charlottesville, elected to close rather than integrate. Upon exiting, we ran into Cainan Townsend, the museum’s director of education and a Farmville native. His father was 11 years old when he started the first grade, and 22 when he graduated from Moton. Today, Townsend says, “You still have that legacy of a generation that was disenfranchised.”

The museum was a sobering conclusion to our visit. But it also confirmed that yeah, Farmville is a worthwhile destination.

Farmville: The list

Hotel Weyanoke: 202 High St., 658-7500, hotelweyanoke.com

Green Front Furniture: 316 N. Main St., 392-5943, greenfront.com

High Bride Trail: visitfarmville.com/high-bridge

Longwood Center for the Visual Arts: 129 N. Main St., 395-2206, lcva.longwood.edu

Mainly Clay: 217 N. Main St., 315-5715, mainlyclay.com

Gladiola Girls: 235 N. Main St., 392-4912, gladiolagirls.com

The Outdoor Adventure Store: 318 N. Main St., 315-5736, theoutdoor adventurestore.com

Charley’s Waterfront Café & Wine Bar: 201 Mill St., 392-1566

Effingham’s: see Hotel Weyanoke

Catbird Rooftop Terrace: see Hotel Weyanoke

North Street Press Club: 127 North St., 392-9444

Moton Museum: 900 Griffin Blvd., 315-8775, motonmuseum.com

Categories
Opinion The Editor's Desk

This week, 10/30

The plaintiffs: Who’s who in the fight to keep Confederate monuments” was a fairly straightforward feature story we published in March, about the 13 people and organizations suing the city over council’s vote to move the Lee and Jackson statues.

As I wrote in an editor’s letter back then, “Much blame (not to mention death threats) has been showered on those who want the statues to be moved, but little attention has been paid to those suing to keep them in place.” Who were the people who cared so deeply about the Confederate monuments, even after the horrific violence of 2017, that they would sue the city to keep them in place? Our story, by then-news editor Lisa Provence, was an attempt to shed light on that question. 

In response, one of those plaintiffs, Edward Dickinson Tayloe II, sued this paper, Provence, and even UVA professor Jalane Schmidt, a source in the story, for $1.7 million, claiming that by relating the facts of his family’s slave-holding history, we were defaming him and implying that he was racist.

Yesterday, in a packed courtroom, Albemarle Circuit Court Judge Claude Worrell dismissed the case, declaring that neither Schmidt’s comments nor the story as a whole were defamatory or libelous. But while it’s a victory for free speech, it still took five months and many thousands of dollars in legal fees to get there. 

SLAPPs (Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation) have, according to the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, “become an all-too-common tool for intimidating and silencing criticism through expensive, baseless legal proceedings.”

Virginia is one of many states that has passed an anti-SLAPP law, but in this case Judge Worrell declined to award attorney’s fees to us or Schmidt, because he was dismissing the case on other grounds. That’s troubling. Eden Heilman, the ACLU attorney representing Schmidt, argues that the mere possibility of a costly legal proceeding can be enough to intimidate people from speaking up, even if the suit is baseless.

The threat of wealthy individuals weaponizing the courts when they are covered in ways they disagree with remains very real. 

Categories
News Uncategorized

In brief: Victory for C-VILLE, new trails, UVA living wage, and more

Case dismissed

Judge throws out defamation lawsuit against C-VILLE and UVA prof

On October 28, the Albemarle Circuit Court ruled in favor of C-VILLE Weekly and former news editor Lisa Provence, concluding that a defamation claim brought by Edward Tayloe II lacked the legal basis to proceed. 

Judge Claude Worrell also ruled in favor of UVA professor Jalane Schmidt, whom Tayloe also sued for defamation, citing comments she made in C-VILLE’s story.

The story at issue, “The Plaintiffs: Who’s who in the fight to keep Confederate monuments,” published in March, profiled the 13 people and organizations suing the city to keep the statues in place. Tayloe’s entry noted his lineage as one of the First Families of Virginia, and included information about his family’s history as one of the largest slave-holding dynasties in the state, a matter of historical record published, among other places, in the 2014 book A Tale of Two Plantations. Schmidt is quoted observing, in respect to Tayloe’s ancestors, “for generations this family has been roiling the lives of black people.”

In May, Tayloe sued the paper, Provence, and Schmidt, alleging that the story and Schmidt’s statements were defamatory because they implied that he was racist, and seeking $1.7 million in damages.

As lawyers for C-VILLE argued in their reply in support of their request to dismiss, Tayloe “does not contend that C-VILLE Weekly got any facts wrong in the article at issue. Instead, he is aggrieved by the truthful, if perhaps uncomfortable, presentation of his family history in connection with an accurate report on a subject of public concern.”

Attorneys for C-VILLE and Schmidt characterized the lawsuit as a SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation), and ACLU attorney Eden Heilman, representing Schmidt, warned of the “chilling effect” that such lawsuits could have on public discussion.

Before giving his decision, Judge Worrell noted that the “political discourse has gotten pretty rough and tumble” and that it “requires all of us to have a pretty thick skin,” except if one has been defamed or libeled. He went on to declare that neither Schmidt’s statements nor C-VILLE’s story as a whole were defamatory or libelous.

The ruling means the case is dismissed and will not go to trial.

 

 


Quote of the week

“It’s both the right and the smart thing to do.” —UVA President Jim Ryan on the university’s decision to expand its living wage plan to include contracted employees.


In brief

Firing back

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit held oral arguments on October 29th on a case to block Dominion Energy from placing a 54,000-horsepower compressor station, fueled by fracked methane gas, in the historically black community of Union Hill in Buckingham County. The Virginia State Air Pollution Control Board—comprised of members appointed by Gov. Ralph Northam, who owns stock in Dominion—issued a permit for the facility in January, inspiring uproar over what supporters call environmental racism.

Land grab

The City of Charlottesville has purchased 142 acres of land adjoining the Ragged Mountain Reservoir, which will be used for trails, environmental education programs, and forest protection, the city announced last week. The city paid $600,000 for the property, most of which was covered by a federal Community Forest Grant, and landowner Louisa Heyward donated the remaining value of the property (roughly $500,000).

Going bagless

For “both budgetary and environmental reasons,” the City of Charlottesville is swapping bagged leaf collection service for vacuum trucks. Starting October 28th, residents can rake their loose leaves to the curb for collection three times a season. Those who insist on bagging leaves can bring them to 1505 Avon Street Extended on Saturdays from 8am-1pm.

Pay raise

UVA announced on October 24 that its major contractors will be paying their full-time workers at least $15 an hour, fulfilling a promise UVA President Jim Ryan made when he raised pay for all full-time UVA employees. The new policy will lift the wages of more than 800 workers, including food service and janitorial staff, and will go into effect January 1.

Showing the receipts 

Days after city residents at the October 21st City Council meeting expressed the need for policy transparency, Mayor Nikuyah Walker has announced that the Charlottesville Police Department will post all policies and general orders to the city’s website, starting in January. At the meeting, speakers said the Police Civilian Review Board should be able to review all CPD policies. Council will vote on a proposed ordinance and bylaws for the CRB on November 4th.